Loved Sundance Catalog? Where to Find Handcrafted Home Goods and Gifts

For decades, the arrival of the Sundance catalog in the mailbox was an event.

Part wish list, part daydream, it was a curated mix of handcrafted pieces that each seemed to carry a story. So when Sundance Catalog closed in September 2025, after a 36-year run that began with Robert Redford’s very first mailer back in 1989, longtime customers lost more than a place to shop. They lost a way of discovering things. If you’ve caught yourself wondering what happened to Sundance Catalog, or searching for stores like Sundance Catalog and turning up nothing that fits, you’re far from alone.

The short answer is that the company closed for good in 2025, winding down its catalog, its website, and its remaining stores.

The harder question is where to go now. Because Sundance spanned apparel, jewelry, and home in equal measure, no single retailer has stepped neatly into its place, and most search results are a maze of generic listicles that miss what made the brand special.

This guide is the honest answer to that question. It points you to where the handcrafted home goods, kitchen pieces, garden accents, and artisan gifts Sundance did so well actually live now, with candid pointers for the apparel and jewelry too. Less “Sundance is gone, shop here,” and more “here is where that feeling lives.”

What Happened to Sundance Catalog?

Sundance launched its very first catalog in the fall of 1989 and spent the next 36 years as a touchstone for Western-inspired, handcrafted living. In 2025 the business, by then operating as Sundance Living, was pushed into Chapter 7 bankruptcy by its creditors and wound down for good that September, closing its website, its remaining stores, and the catalog itself. There was no acquisition and no obvious successor, which is exactly why so many former customers have been left looking for somewhere new to shop.

What Made Sundance Feel Like Sundance

Before the alternatives, it helps to name what actually made Sundance feel like Sundance. If you connect with anything in this list, the recommendations that follow will make far more sense.

• Handcrafted character. Pieces that looked made by a person, not a machine. Texture, a little intentional imperfection, and a sense of provenance mattered more than mass-market polish.
• The discovery experience. A curated, edited assortment that felt like a treasure hunt rather than an endless scroll.
• A global, rustic aesthetic. Western, bohemian, and globally sourced, built on natural materials, warm tones, and visible artisan technique.
• A gifting destination. Sundance was a reliable source for distinctive, artisan gifts across a wide range of price points.
• A story worth telling. Customers liked knowing a piece had an origin and a maker.

One honest caveat shapes everything below. Sundance was really three stores in one: apparel, jewelry, and home plus gifts. This guide focuses on the home and gift side, where that handcrafted character truly lives and where the strongest replacements exist. It still points you toward apparel and jewelry options, because a guide that pretends a single store can do it all is missing the mark.

Where to Shop Now: Stores Like Sundance Catalog

Because no single retailer replaces all of Sundance, the most useful way to organize this is by what you’re actually shopping for. Quick, honest pointers for apparel and jewelry first, then the heart of the guide: where to find handcrafted home goods, kitchen and garden pieces, and gifts.

For the Apparel and Jewelry Shoppers

If it was the Western-inspired clothing and footwear you loved most, your closest landing spots are dedicated apparel brands rather than home retailers. Johnny Was leans into the same bohemian, artfully patterned sensibility, while Garnet Hill covers the relaxed, natural-fiber side of the Sundance wardrobe.

For Sundance’s artisan and Western jewelry, look to specialists like Peyote Bird, along with the many independent makers who once supplied Sundance and now sell directly through their own sites.

For the Home, Kitchen, Garden, and Gift Shoppers

This is where Sundance’s handcrafted spirit really lived, and where you have the best chance of recreating it. Here are four options worth knowing, with fair pros and cons for each.

Novica

• What they do well: A large global artisan marketplace with rich storytelling about makers.
• The trade-off: The huge range can feel less curated, with varying styles and quality.
• Best for: Shoppers who want maximum selection and don’t mind curating.

Ten Thousand Villages

• What they do well: One of the original fair trade retailers with decades of partnerships.
• The trade-off: More traditional look; online experience is less polished.
• Best for: Shoppers who value artisan credentials and in-store browsing.

VivaTerra

• What they do well: A rustic, eco-leaning home brand with an aesthetic close to Sundance’s.
• The trade-off: Focuses more on larger home decor than small gifts.
• Best for: Those chasing Sundance’s home decor look.

SERRV

• What they do well: A deep handcrafted assortment across kitchen, home, garden, food, and gifts, with curated collections that recreate the catalog feel.
• The trade-off: No Western apparel or fine jewelry; globally sourced rather than specifically Western.
• Best for: Shoppers who loved Sundance’s handcrafted home and gift side.

How to Spot Catalog-Quality Artisan Goods Anywhere You Shop

• Look for named makers, not vague claims.
• Favor curation over endless scroll.
• Check for a real range of price points.
• Judge gift-readiness.
• Trust texture and detail.

The Catalog Is Gone. The Feeling Doesn’t Have to Be.

The catalog may be gone, but the pleasure of discovering beautiful, handcrafted, character-rich things has not. That experience has simply moved.

If it was the handcrafted side of Sundance you loved most, specifically the home, the kitchen, the garden, and the gifts, we would be glad for you to explore what SERRV has built over 75 years. Start with our curated Story Worlds collections for that same sense of discovery: Warm Bread Nights for slow evenings at the table, Host-Ready Kitchen for gatherings, Porch & Garden Sanctuary for outdoor corners, and Cozy Home for everyday comfort. Or browse our handcrafted Home, Kitchen, Garden, and Gifts collections directly.

The catalog taught a generation of shoppers to value the made-by-hand over the mass-produced. Keeping that alive is exactly why we’re here.